Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach: Where to find & better choice between Karlach or Anders in BG3


Use our Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach guide to learn where and how to find Karlach & which is a better choice between Karlach or Anders in BG3.

baldur’s gate 3 karlach, karlach baldur’s gate 3, karlach bg3, better choice between baldur's gate 3 karlach and anders, bg3 karlach and anders, how to find baldur’s gate 3 karlach, how to locate karlach in baldur’s gate 3, where to find karlach in bg3, how to get karlach join your party in bg3
Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach: Where to find & better choice between Karlach or Anders in BG3

Making decisions in Baldur’s Gate 3 can be quite the challenge, as this CRPG is all about choices that shape your journey. One such dilemma involves aiding local paladins in their hunt for a devil. While the solution might appear straightforward, delving deeper reveals a more nuanced answer for optimal outcomes.

The question arises: Should You Side With Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach Or Anders? In this guide, we’ll explore this choice to help you navigate the complexities and make the right decision. We will also know how to find our Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach at the end of this guide.

The better choice between Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach and Anders

Undoubtedly, in Baldur’s Gate 3, the better choice is to stand by Karlach rather than Anders. Despite the quest’s premise of battling a devil, what unfolds is the discovery of a battered Tiefling named Karlach. Her intriguing narrative revolves around a mechanical heart and a painful past.

Notably, Karlach is recruitable as a Barbarian companion. She unveils that the supposed paladins are devil servants, pursuing her after her daring escape. Opting for Karlach unveils a richer, more compassionate path in this complex tale.

CHECK OUT: Best Karlach Build in Baldur’s Gate 3

Why Choosing Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach is Better?

When considering whether to side with Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach or Anders, it’s important to weigh the options carefully. Opting to eliminate Karlach might seem like a simpler path, promising the tempting Sword of Justice from Anders as an immediate reward. However, this decision limits your gains to a weapon and potentially misses out on a valuable ally. 

On the other hand, aligning with Karlach can unveil intriguing twists. Confronting the Tyr Paladins reveals their hidden motives, making it a wise choice to eliminate them. This approach not only secures the coveted sword but also leaves you with a satisfying outcome.

A significant factor to consider is Shadowheart’s reaction. She harbors a strong fondness for Karlach, and not siding with her could lead to lasting resentment. Choosing Karlach sets you on a different trajectory, where she becomes a pivotal companion. Her help in finding a parasite cure and addressing her infernal engine heart’s mechanics presents intriguing plot points.

Still, this decision doesn’t come without challenges. Wyll, a fellow traveler, opposes Karlach’s inclusion due to his devilish concerns. Overcoming this, he allows her presence but faces a drastic transformation as penance. 

Furthermore, the consequences of siding with Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach extend beyond confronting Zariel’s agents in Paladin’s disguise. As you tread this intricate path, thoughtful consideration is essential to shape your experience.

CHECK OUT: Baldur’s Gate 3 Shadowheart: How to save and romance Shadowheart in BG3

Where and How to Find Karlach in Baldur’s Gate 3?

To locate Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach, you can easily do so by initiating a conversation with Wyll at the Druid Grove and enlisting his help. His initial quest involves the search for Karlach, which consequently leads to a marked yellow area on your map. 

Precisely, Karlach’s precise location is situated on the Risen Road, positioned towards the southeast of the designated area (coordinates: X:111, Y:503). As you venture along the narrow river in this vicinity, you’ll come across Karlach, triggering an interactive cutscene upon approaching her closely.

Here are the details on how you can find Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach:

  • Start at the Beach: When you land on the beach, go towards the north. Pass through the broken ruins and the Nautiloid shipwreck until you see a large fortified gate. This gate leads to the Hollow and the Emerald Grove.
  • Goblin Fight and Hollow: After a big fight with goblins near the gate, head into the Hollow. Here, you can ask Wyll to join your group. He’s looking for Karlach, thinking she’s a dangerous devil that could harm the Sword Coast.
  • Back Outside the Gate: Go back to the area outside the big gate. Then, follow the path towards the west into the Forest. When you cross a bridge, turn north where you’ll see a pile of adventurers and goblins’ remains on a dirt path.
  • Meet Scratch: Follow this path going north until you come across Scratch. If you can talk to animals, you can convince Scratch to come to your camp. Keep going past Scratch and reach the rocks at X:79, and Y:499 to jump across the river and get to the Risen Road.
  • Risen Road: As you land on the Risen Road, immediately go east. You’ll spot a bloody log and Karlach nearby.

However, be cautious. If Wyll is with you, he might want to harm Karlach. You’ll need to use your persuasive skills to calm him down and prevent any aggression.

CHECK OUT: Best Shadowheart Build in Baldur’s Gate 3

How To Make Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach Join Your Party?

Talking to Karlach is the key. Similar to other companions, she shares her story and background. You can ask her to join you after she explains. If your party has space, she comes along; otherwise, she heads to your camp.

When you have Wyll in your group, you’ll need to persuade him to back off. In the conversation, avoid choosing the third option in both dialogue selections. This way, Wyll will realize the deception and withdraw. If Wyll isn’t with you, the same talk will happen at camp by day’s end. Just don’t suggest attacking Karlach for the same result. Talk to Wyll after his first chat with Karlach to progress his quest.

Without Wyll, skip the choice to kill Karlach. Your tadpole link will reveal she was forced into the Blood War. After introductions, Karlach explains fake ‘Paladins of Tyr,’ Zariel’s hunters after her. Aid her against them and she’ll join, or she’ll head to your camp if your party’s full.

karlach, karlach bg3, baldur's gate 3 karlach, best karlach build, best bg3 karlach spells, best bg3 karlach armor, best bg3 karlach items, bg3 karlach stats, bg3 karlach melee build, bg3 karlach ranged build

CHECK OUT: Best Baldur’s Gate 3 Weapons: Skills, Abilities, Locations, and more

Well, that is all that you need to know about Baldur’s Gate 3 Karlach, including her location, ways to find her, and the better choice between Karlach or Anders.

For constant updates, keep following Gamevro.

Mohit is a freelance writer who loves writing games related blogs and news. When he's not writing, he's either reading fantasy books or playing the newest video games. He's a big fan of Mass Effect game series. Mohit really likes role-playing games, and sometimes he thinks of everyday conversations like a choose-your-own-adventure game.


Resident Evil 1 Remake, Resident Evil Remake, Resident Evil 9, re1 Remake, RE 9, Resident Evil 1 Remake In Development and Leon Is Lead For Resident Evil 9

Resident Evil 1 Remake In Development and Leon Is Lead For RE 9, claims...

Since the release of the Resident Evil 4 remake in 2023, fans have been speculating about the future of Capcom's iconic survival horror series....
Warner Bros, Adult Swim Games, Adult Swim Games and Warner Bros, Warner Bros Returning Adult Swim Games Back To Original Developers

Warner Bros. Returning Adult Swim Games Back To Original Developers

Several developers claim they have regained control of their indie titles after Warner Bros. seemingly decided to reconsider its decision to delist all Adult Swim...
Hellblade 2 Achievements, Hellblade 2 Achievement list, Hellblade 2 trophy list, Hellblade 2 trophies, Senua’s Saga Hellblade 2 Achievement List Revealed

Senua’s Saga Hellblade 2 Achievement and Trophy List Revealed

The complete Senua’s Saga Hellblade 2 achievement and trophy list has recently been revealed. Senua's Saga: Hellblade 2 is set to release on Xbox and...
Call of Duty Black Ops 6, Call of Duty Black Ops 6 on Xbox Game Pass, cod 2024 on xbox game pass, Call of Duty Black Ops 6 Xbox, Xbox Game Pass To Make Changes To Its Tiers To Add Call of Duty Black Ops 6

Xbox Game Pass To Make Changes To Its Tiers To Add Call of Duty...

On May 17, The Wall Street Journal reported that Call of Duty 2024 will be available on Xbox Game Pass from day one. Following...